Looking for a honest Cutco review? Is Cutco Cutlery a legit MLM or another pyramid scheme? You have probably seen on social media Cutco Cutlery is a great way to earn money form selling knives and other Cutco Products via Vector Marketing. Is it legit, and if so, are the commissions worth the time and effort. Lets dive in and find out.
But before we do, I started Affiliated Success for one reason, and one reason only – to find the best way to make money online. When I started out I jumped from one program to the next, getting scammed, getting ripped off and I decided I wanted to make sure no one else had to do it, if I could help it.
Making money online doesn’t have to be hard. In fact the concepts and systems are quite simple. What is difficult is the commitment and dedication needed to succeed. Most people fail because they are not willing to put in the work. Plain and simple.
My number one recommendation is one of the most successful programs I have ever come across. It has helped me make the most money online and taught me how to do it without spending any money. If you are serious about making money online, you have to check this out. You may even recognise the founder if you have read my Affiliate Bootcamp Summit Review (hint he features as one of the experts on the panel).
Sign up TODAY and learn how to quickly build and scale a PROFITABLE online business!
Check Out My Number 1 Recommendation For Making Money Online. This Simple Program Has Made Me The MOST Money!
What is Cutco Cutlery?
Cutco Cutlery, also known as Cutco Knives, operates as a direct sales organization with its headquarters located in Olean, New York.
The company specializes in the production and distribution of superior kitchen cutlery, cookware, gardening tools, flatware, and various other kitchen accoutrements, in addition to hunting, sporting, and pocket knives. However, Cutco Cutlery has cultivated a reputation primarily for its high-grade kitchen knives and knife sets.
As we delve into the question: ‘Is Cutco a pyramid scheme or a legitimate MLM?’ in this 2023 review, it is important to note the company’s historical trajectory. Cutco Cutlery was established in 1949 as a joint venture between Alcoa and Case Cutlery, originally bearing the name Alcas Corporation.
The series of events led Alcoa to acquire Case in 1972, followed by a full acquisition of the company by Alcas Management a decade later. After another three years, Alcas expanded by procuring Vector Marketing Corporation, which serves as the company’s sales arm. A detailed exploration of Vector Marketing’s story will be discussed further in this review.
Currently, it’s estimated that Cutco Cutlery’s products have reached millions of households globally. As a privately held entity, Cutco Cutlery does not offer its shares on public exchanges.
The company operates under a direct sales framework, and we will delve into the question of whether it represents a pyramid scheme or a multi-level marketing structure in due course. Apart from its sales of knives, Cutco Cutlery is recognized for providing sales employment opportunities to demographics such as stay-at-home parents, college students, and high-school graduates, requiring no prior experience.
Its business model fundamentally relies on the recruitment and training of individuals to vend knives, providing them a commission-based income. Sales also occur via its website and during planned events across various locations. Essentially, this approach deviates from traditional business models that utilize wholesalers and retailers as intermediaries in the supply chain.
All Cutco knives are manufactured in America, backed by a lifetime guarantee.
Now, we shall proceed to a comprehensive analysis of their marketing division, Vector Marketing.
What is Vector Marketing?
Vector Marketing may be perceived as the sales division of Cutco Cutlery.
Could you elaborate on how this functions?
Throughout its operational history, Cutco Cutlery has identified itself as a direct sales organization.
In the initial phases of its journey, Cutco Cutlery lacked a primary distributor. Its products were vended by a myriad of independent, small-scale, direct sellers and it had not singled out a preferred direct sales company.
However, in 1981, the emergence of Vector Marketing Corporation brought about significant changes, as it rapidly began to outpace all other independent sellers in sales performance. Consequently, in 1985, Cutco procured Vector Marketing, making it its principal seller. The successful model employed by Vector was subsequently replicated across Cutco’s operations, resulting in the two companies becoming intertwined.
Ultimately, Cutco operates as a single-level direct sales organization, implying that Vector Sales Representatives cannot establish downlines and earn commissions from new recruits, as seen in MLM structures.
Contrary to certain online speculations claiming that Vector handles the ‘MLM operations’ for Cutco, the reality is that Vector functions as the exclusive at-home distributor of Cutco knives.
Thus, present-day interactions, such as receiving a call from a company receptionist or viewing an employment opportunity advertisement, are most likely from Vector Marketing rather than Cutco directly.
Over the years, Vector Marketing has attracted criticism for what many consider as unethical recruitment strategies. It has frequently been accused of disseminating misleading information, with a particular focus on targeting college students, stay-at-home parents, and high school graduates with ostensibly lucrative side-job opportunities without sufficiently communicating the realistic earning potential.
Vector Marketing has weathered numerous legal battles, with a notable lawsuit in Wisconsin accusing the company of allegedly incorporating false or misleading information in its advertisements.
Complaints from many who have been associated with Vector Marketing reveal that their income was minimal, and in fact, a significant proportion claimed to have incurred losses through their engagement with the company. A survey conducted by The Washington Post in 1996 confirmed this sentiment, with half of the 940 Vector recruits admitting that they were unable to make any profit, with some indeed reporting financial losses.
In response to what was perceived as predatory recruitment practices by Vector Marketing, a group of students formed an organization known as SAVE (Students Against Vector Exploitation) to resist the company’s methods.
It is critical to highlight that these allegations have been directed at Vector Marketing and not Cutco.
Despite these controversies, Vector Marketing has managed to navigate through the challenges and has continued to market Cutco Cutlery products consistently.
What Products Can You Sell With Cutco Cutlery?
Cutco Cutlery’s scope extends beyond simply the sale of knives. The brand offers a diverse range of products to its clientele.
It’s noteworthy that Cutco knives, undeniably their most sought-after item, have become synonymous with the brand itself.
The company provides Homemaker Sets comprising meticulously crafted blades, lauded for being among the finest quality available in the market.
The product catalogue is extensive, including Cook’s Tools, Tableware, additional Cutlery items, Cookware, Pots, Pans, culinary gadgets, baking tools, utensils, and cutting boards.
One of the appealing factors of Cutco products, especially their knives, is the use of durable, premium-grade materials in their construction. An illustrative example is the use of thermo-resin in the manufacture of their knife handles, which bolsters their resistance to repeated dishwasher cycles while maintaining their strength and durability.
This commitment to quality and durability is carried through all their product lines, a factor that contributes to the brand’s presence in an estimated 16 million homes.
Here is an overarching catalogue of the products offered by Cutco (Kindly note that availability may vary and some products could be discontinued at the time of reference):
Knives and Knife Sets
The highest revenue-generating product offered by the company is Cutco Knives.
This category encompasses a variety of kitchen knives, table knives, outdoor knives, and accompanying storage solutions.
The assortment of knives offered by the company includes Bread Knives, Carving Knives, Cheese Knives, Chef Knives, Fruit & Vegetable Knives, Specialty Knives, Table Knife Sets, and the French Knife.
In relation to storage solutions, Cutco provides Wood Blocks, Knife Trays, Drawer Organizers, Countertop Organizers, Wall Organizers, and Knife Sheaths.
Among the company’s top-selling products are the Cutco Knife Sets, featuring the company’s patented recessed ‘Double D,’ 440A stainless steel blade with a recessed edge renowned for delivering precise cuts.
Specialty scissors or shears enjoy significant popularity among Cutco’s customer base.
The shears’ versatility extends from kitchen utility to outdoor use, capable of cutting a wide array of items from vegetables to metallic objects. Demonstrations have shown these shears capable of cutting pennies, dimes, and quarters.
Cutco’s outdoor product range includes items such as hunting knives, pocket knives, sporting knives, and gardening tools.
Cutco Cutlery Lifetime Guarantee?
An additional incentive for customers to invest in Cutco knives is the lifetime guarantee provided by the company.
Cutco assures its clients that should they find any of their products dissatisfactory in performance, the company will make the necessary rectifications, given that the product is being used as recommended.
This Lifetime Guarantee applies to all Cutco products, regardless of whether you were the original purchaser or if the item was received as a gift.
The procedure is simple; send the product in need of sharpening or repair, and it will undergo a meticulous multi-step process before being returned in near-new condition. Cutco does not require a receipt or product registration.
Should Cutco products become damaged due to unconventional use, the company offers replacement at half the price, including the applicable sales tax.
Earning Revenue with Cutco Cutlery
There exists an opportunity to generate income by selling Cutco Products, although it is important to note that this is not a simple task. Face-to-face sales may not suit everyone, which is also a reason why many individuals are unable to establish their own businesses.
However, this does not negate the possibility of achieving monetary success by selling knives, provided you’re willing to invest sufficient effort. Several individuals have managed to earn substantial revenue by selling these products, often starting with no prior experience.
The pathway to becoming a sales representative is relatively straightforward:
- Attend an interview.
- After being hired, undergo a three-day training course.
- Provide a list of potential leads.
- You are then furnished with a sales script and a presentation, which will guide your interactions with potential clients. Sales representatives are encouraged to gather contact information, including phone numbers and email addresses, from prospective buyers for inclusion in the client database.
Previously, Vector Marketing required sales representatives to purchase a kit for their presentations.
Currently, Cutco Cutlery provides the kit free of charge to active representatives.
An active representative is defined as a salesperson required to sell a minimum of $100 worth of cutlery or cookware each month.
If the sales representatives do not meet this target, they are obligated to return the kit or purchase it at half the price to continue sales operations.
Cutco Cutlery’s Compensation Plan
The compensation plan is quite straightforward as it operates under a single-level direct sales model.
Uniquely, Cutco Cutlery (under Vector Marketing) guarantees its sales representatives a specific wage for each appointment. This is not a standard practice in the direct sales industry, where most companies rely solely on commissions.
The exact payment offered by Cutco varies based on geographical location.
There has been confusion with individuals misconstruing the ‘per appointment’ rate as an hourly wage, mainly because a typical appointment lasts approximately one hour.
This misunderstanding led to controversies, with claims of promised $15 hourly wages. However, it was clarified that representatives earn $15 per successful in-person appointment with prospective buyers, which generally lasts around an hour.
In addition to this guaranteed wage per appointment, Cutco Cutlery also offers commissions on your sales.
Cutco Cutlery employs two forms of compensation plans: the Basic Cutco Compensation Plan and the Cutco At Home Compensation Plan.
The Cutco At Home Compensation Plan offers two avenues for earnings: sales commissions and bonuses generated from your downline sales.
A typical commission structure would be as follows:
- $0 – $1,000 in sales = 10% commission
- $1,001 – $4,000 in sales = 15% commission
- $4,001 – $7,500 in sales = 20% commission
- $7,501 – $12,000 in sales = 25% commission
- $12,000 – $24,000 in sales = 30% commission
- Sales exceeding $24,000 = 30%+ commission (the “+” is unspecified) To receive payment, representatives must submit a qualified presentation report to their office manager each week.
It’s also worth noting that representatives are required to sign a standard Sales Representative Agreement and provide a security deposit of $200 for their demonstration knives in some cases.
Pros of Cutco Cutlery
Cutco guarantees $15 per successful client presentation, a feature that was previously misunderstood as an hourly payment. The potential for additional earnings arises if your prospects decide to make a purchase.
For those passionate about sales, this guaranteed wage stands out compared to most direct sales companies.
Quality Cutco consistently receives positive feedback on the quality of its products, often earning customer recommendations. Notably, chefs, butchers, and everyday users endorse Cutco products, reinforcing their high-quality reputation.
Selling a high-quality product simplifies the job – the main task becomes showcasing your persuasion skills and identifying customer needs.
Training Provided by Vector Marketing
Vector Marketing, serving as Cutco’s primary sales arm, offers extensive training to its new recruits. Given that many of their employees are high school or college students with minimal sales experience, this training proves valuable.
Vector Marketing provides sales representatives with written sales pitch scripts, along with prepared responses to handle potential rejections.
The training offered by Vector Marketing extends beyond immediate sales skills. It can be applied to future roles in your career, especially those involving sales. Field experience further helps develop essential communication skills, including self-presentation and handling rejections.
Life Skills Training
Regardless of your interest in sales or earning money through selling Cutco knives, the sales training you receive can be beneficial in other aspects of your life. For instance, it can enhance your interpersonal skills, which are valuable in various situations, from job interviews to personal relationships.
Broad Social Media Presence
Cutco Cutlery boasts a considerable social media following, indicating significant brand awareness. This broad reach can assist you on the field, particularly when you encounter someone already familiar with the brand or considering a purchase due to the publicity.
Cutco goes the extra mile to provide an exceptional after-sales experience. They offer a lifetime guarantee on their products, promising free repairs and knife sharpening services, assuring their customers of lasting value.
Cons of Cutco Cutlery
Potential Deceptive Recruiting Tactics
Accusations of deceptive recruiting practices by Cutco/Vector Marketing are prevalent online. However, the situation is more complex. With numerous branches, the honesty level of managers can vary significantly. Some are straightforward, while others may be misleading, contributing to Vector Marketing’s occasionally negative reputation. It’s crucial to recognize this difference.
Vector Marketing’s working model doesn’t suit everyone, leading to high employee turnover. Many people enter with unrealistic expectations, which can result in disappointment. The design of the recruitment process, seemingly intentional, often fails to establish realistic job expectations for potential hires.
Absence of Overhead Cost Reimbursement
Given that this is not a traditional sales job, the company doesn’t reimburse the costs incurred while selling their products. You’ll need to cover expenses such as car insurance, fuel, meals, and phone charges. This lack of reimbursement can be particularly frustrating, especially when considering the potential for passive income through various online programs.
Despite the exceptional quality of Cutco Cutlery products, the premium pricing may be prohibitive for the average family. This price range, often beyond the reach of many potential customers, can negatively impact your sales figures.
Risk of Alienation from Friends and Family
Vector Marketing’s strategy often involves selling to friends and family. This approach can lead to strained relationships if your loved ones perceive you as incessantly pushing expensive products onto them.
Outdated Sales Tactics
The sales method, largely based on door-to-door sales and script use, may not be the most effective in a post-COVID world or in an era of prevalent online shopping. Although Cutco Cutlery has an online store, door-to-door salespeople could find themselves at a competitive disadvantage. However, the technique can still be effective in specific situations, such as selling to those unaware of the online store.
Can You Make Money Selling Cutco Knives?
Earning money with Cutco Cutlery is feasible, though it might not be as straightforward as the company suggests.
Substantial initial effort is required, often without any assurances of success. This can be a challenging endeavor, particularly for individuals who are not naturally inclined towards sales. Interestingly, the company often recruits individuals without considering their past experience or credentials.
This recruitment approach potentially explains Cutco Cutlery’s high employee attrition rate, as many hires may not inherently possess the necessary skills or temperament for a sales role.
To many, the opportunity appears attractive in theory, often leading to excitement and high expectations. However, they may not fully comprehend the practical challenges associated with in-home sales until they experience it firsthand.
On a positive note, individuals with the right personality traits, particularly those who can manage frequent rejections, often excel and achieve financial success. These individuals constitute the success stories of Cutco Cutlery.
Is Cutco Cutlery A Multi-Level Marketing Scheme?
Cutco Cutlery does not operate as a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) entity.
To clarify, an MLM scheme, by definition, is a network marketing program characterized by a hierarchical structure that encourages members to recruit new individuals, subsequently forming a network.
In MLM, members earn from two primary streams. One is a commission from the direct sale of products, and the second is a share of the sales made by the individuals they have recruited, often referred to as their ‘downline’ or ‘sales team’. Hence, the emphasis on financial gain is closely tied to the creation and growth of this downline.
This structure is not evident in Cutco Cutlery’s model or that of its affiliate, Vector Marketing. They do not incentivize the recruitment of new members into an individual’s downline, primarily because such a downline does not exist within their system. Their compensation is based purely on securing appointments and direct sales, diverging from the typical MLM model.
Is Cutco Cutlery A Pyramid Scheme?
Cutco Knives does not fit the definition of a pyramid scheme.
To explain, a pyramid scheme, which is considered unlawful, functions through a business model where a limited number of top-level members recruit new participants, accumulating most of the profit while the majority of members earn little or lose their investment.
In a standard pyramid scheme, newly recruited members pay a joining fee, which is subsequently distributed through the higher ranks. Notably, in such a setup, the emphasis leans heavily towards recruitment efforts rather than the sale of products with genuine value. This characteristic is a significant factor when determining if a company operates as a pyramid scheme.
However, Cutco Knives does not meet these criteria. The company takes pride in the sale of its quality products, thereby demonstrating it prioritizes the sale of its merchandise over recruitment, which is characteristic of a pyramid scheme.
Upon examination, Cutco Cutlery seems less likely to be a pyramid scheme than a Multi-Level Marketing (MLM) company, and we have already established it does not fit the latter’s typical model. Consequently, it is safe to say that Cutco Cutlery does not operate as a pyramid scheme.
Is Cutco Cutlery A Scam?
No I do not think Cutco Cutlery is a Scam. Unfortunately due to the industry they operate in, and some of their practises they have tarnished their public image. Will they ever be able to break away from this? Time will tell, but it will undoubtably make it harder to make money.
Is Cutco Cutlery A Legit Way to Make Money Online – The Verdict
Cutco Cutlery stands as a reputable company that manufactures high-quality products, and concurrently presents opportunities for individuals, especially those without prior experience, to generate income as sales representatives.
Over the years, the company has faced criticism over the recruitment methods employed by its marketing division, Vector Marketing. The primary critique arises from the perception that the recruitment process predominantly targets inexperienced salespeople, promising them lucrative monetary prospects.
While this unconventional sales position suits some individuals, who often profit from selling Cutco Cutlery, it does not align with the capabilities or interests of the majority.
Viewing Cutco in the capacity of a manufacturer of kitchen knives and related products, the company’s excellence is evident. It stands out among competitors due to the superior quality of its products, backed by a lifetime guarantee, an offer few companies provide.
The company’s products consistently garner positive reviews, available for perusal online. Moreover, many experts endorse Cutco knives and the company enjoys considerable recognition on social media platforms. However, the reliability of social media metrics should be cautiously interpreted.
The public discourse around Cutco often involves derogatory terms such as the “Cutco pyramid scheme”, predominantly based on the company’s sales approach. Yet, when examined objectively, Cutco’s operation aligns more closely with a unique, yet genuine, direct sales model rather than a get-rich-quick scheme.
If the sales position offered by Cutco does not suit your capabilities or interests, numerous other opportunities for income generation exist, particularly in the online domain that do not necessitate sales expertise.
In the current online environment, it’s unfortunate that many individuals encounter dubious actors. Consequently, I have been conducting reviews of investment opportunities and online platforms for passive income generation. Through this process, I have identified a number of promising opportunities worth considering:
One Last Thing Before You Go…
Cutco Cutlery definitely has some potential, but the bad press will be hard to shake. I have tried so many programs and systems I have lost count. The ones that were not scams all have their strengths and weaknesses but the one that resonated the most with me, and has made me the most money, was developed by one of the 16 super affiliates, Jacob Caris.
Jacob has developed a simple 3 step system for building a super affiliate business – you could say his resume definitely shows he is cut out for the job! It is aptly named Super Affiliate Accelerator. The great thing about his system is it does not require any tech skills, and can be used from anyone to a complete beginner to a seasoned veteran.
In fact it has recently been so successful I have started to see other programs scrambled and doing damage control as students are leaving to come to Super Affiliate Accelerator.
If you are serious about building a profitable online business, and growing to become a super affiliate this program is for you. Jacob does not accept everyone however. You must be willing to put in work, and be committed to succeeding – otherwise he will turn you away. Sound like you? Click the link below to get started.
Check Out My Number 1 Recommendation For Making Money Online. This Simple Program Has Made Me The MOST Money!